One vertex per element, one color per generator, with an edge from x to x·s.
(1,2)(3,9)(4,7)(5,8)(6,11)(10,15)(12,14)(13,16)(19,25)(22,26)(27,31)(30,32)(33,34,38,43,37,42,51,40)(35,44,47,53,46,39,52,55)(36,41,50,59,49,58,62,56)(45,57,60,63,48,54,61,64)(1,3,5,11)(2,6,8,9)(4,10,12,16)(7,13,14,15)(17,18)(19,26)(20,28)(21,23)(22,25)(24,29)(27,30)(31,32)(33,35)(34,39)(36,48)(37,46)(38,47)(40,53)(41,57)(42,44)(43,55)(45,49)(50,61)(51,52)(54,58)(56,64)(59,63)(60,62)(1,4,5,12)(2,7,8,14)(3,10,11,16)(6,13,9,15)(17,19)(18,22)(20,27)(21,25)(23,26)(24,30)(28,32)(29,31)(34,40)(38,51)(39,53)(41,56)(42,43)(44,55)(47,52)(50,62)(54,63)(57,64)(58,59)(60,61)(3,11)(6,9)(10,16)(13,15)(18,23)(19,25)(24,28)(27,31)(33,36)(34,41)(35,45)(37,49)(38,50)(39,54)(40,56)(42,58)(43,59)(44,57)(46,48)(47,60)(51,62)(52,61)(53,63)(55,64) involution — undirected(2,8)(6,9)(7,14)(13,15)(17,20,21,29)(18,24,23,28)(19,27,25,31)(22,30,26,32)(34,42)(35,46)(36,49)(40,43)(47,52)(50,62)(54,57)(63,64)A Cayley diagram is a choice, not a fact about the group. Another drawing of this group — in a book, or on a different generating set — may look nothing like this one.